Warrior General Games

I don't understand how my teams KR/PR ( Kenyatta Stokes) isn't the MVP with PR TD's way higher than anyone else.

https://glb.warriorgeneral.com/game/stats.pl?season=95&league_id=37&conference_id=0&stat=sp_teams&sort=punt_return_td&playoffs=0&stat_type=raw

MVP is based off of Blowout adjusted stats, not Raw. Most of your games were complete blowouts.

But also pretty sure the MVP stuff has been broken for a long time.

Originally posted by Seric
MVP is based off of Blowout adjusted stats, not Raw. Most of your games were complete blowouts.

But also pretty sure the MVP stuff has been broken for a long time.

Yup.

Blowout adjusted stats look close except one category makes it obvious who should have won
Stat: MVP - Runner up
KR avg: 22.6 - 24
KR TDs: 2 - 1.29
PR avg: 17 - 18.2
PR TDs: 8.91 - 21.8******
RetYDs: 3954.54 - 3848.83

We have the same problem since we reboot- KP's returner should be MVP every season, based on the blowout adjusted stats it so obvious. However she always finish second to a player with many less TDs and much worse overall stats. The owner of our team say it is because our team scores a lot more points, and the MVP rankings favor the player who score the most % of their teams points. So like if a team sucks and they only scored 100 points all season but the returner got 11 PR TDs, he will win instead of the returner with 22 TDs on a team that scored 500 points that season. Maybe that is the reason but it seems like that reason is broke. Either the rankings are broke or the reason is broke but to me its still broke either way you look at it.

Originally posted by Jeff Williams
We have the same problem since we reboot- KP's returner should be MVP every season, based on the blowout adjusted stats it so obvious. However she always finish second to a player with many less TDs and much worse overall stats. The owner of our team say it is because our team scores a lot more points, and the MVP rankings favor the player who score the most % of their teams points. So like if a team sucks and they only scored 100 points all season but the returner got 11 PR TDs, he will win instead of the returner with 22 TDs on a team that scored 500 points that season. Maybe that is the reason but it seems like that reason is broke. Either the rankings are broke or the reason is broke but to me its still broke either way you look at it.

It's been broke for a long time. Prior to being broken, it wasn't always the best but it was more accurate. That's why I'm happy they changed the equipment from automatically going to the MVP and now randomly going to one of the top 3 or 5 (can't remember the actual number, but I think it's the top 3). So, yeah you don't get the MVP, but you have a chance of getting the EQ which lasts all season, if memory serves me right.

At least it's not some random offensive lineman

https://glb.warriorgeneral.com/game/league.pl?league_id=112

Was many seasons ago when there was a ranting post about an O-lineman winning the ST MVP and he played exactly 1... yes... 1 game on ST's. As Seric said... broke. Unfortunately, ST's never got the same respect as Offense and Defense so I suspect attention to detail on ST MVP likely didn't happen either.

Originally posted by Theo Wizzago
Was many seasons ago when there was a ranting post about an O-lineman winning the ST MVP and he played exactly 1... yes... 1 game on ST's. As Seric said... broke. Unfortunately, ST's never got the same respect as Offense and Defense so I suspect attention to detail on ST MVP likely didn't happen either.

This 100%

KR Yards (not average) factors big time into the ST MVP calculation from what I have seen over the years

blowout adjusted, the MVP beat your guy 1844 to 623

it's why when you see idiots gaming the system for ST MVP's they only set up for the return team so the offense and defense suck and they get lots of KR yards

Originally posted by Jeff Williams
We have the same problem since we reboot- KP's returner should be MVP every season, based on the blowout adjusted stats it so obvious. However she always finish second to a player with many less TDs and much worse overall stats. The owner of our team say it is because our team scores a lot more points, and the MVP rankings favor the player who score the most % of their teams points. So like if a team sucks and they only scored 100 points all season but the returner got 11 PR TDs, he will win instead of the returner with 22 TDs on a team that scored 500 points that season. Maybe that is the reason but it seems like that reason is broke. Either the rankings are broke or the reason is broke but to me its still broke either way you look at it.



Muad'Dib FTW

I'm sure it will get fixed soon!

Thanks for all the replies everyone!

Originally posted by regnac
I'm sure it will get fixed soon!

Thanks for all the replies everyone!

optimism is nice LOL