Warrior General Games

Kickers and punters have their own MVP. There is no reason for them to be in the OMVP rankings.

In the situations where this happens, they are detracting from the ability of offensive players to win the MVP equipment. This should not happen simply because a team in the conference is incompetent at getting into the end zone.

If kickers can be OMVP, why not punt returners? They play on 4th down just like kickers, and they can be responsible for yards gained AND points. Obviously, the answer is "They're not offensive players, so no offensive MVP." And that is exactly my point. If it doesn't apply to punt returners, it has no business applying to kickers.

It's a very simple fix, so I don't see why this couldn't be accomplished.

1) Will it improve the user experience with the game
Yes, as users who have offensive players will have a better chance of winning MVP/equipment for their players.

2) Is there a business reason for implementing the suggestion
Yes, as being cheated out of an MVP or equipment can detract users from continuing with the game.

3) Does the cost of devoting the coding time to implementing the suggestion make sense
I can't imagine it would take very much time or coding to stop kickers for being eligible for the MVP.

saw this last season, and the season before.

Kicker are people too, man.

Laces out Dan

Can the kicker ever lose the kicker MVP if they win the offensive MVP? Seems like getting double credit.

-1 stupid suggestion. Make better dots.

Originally posted by coachingubigr
-1 stupid suggestion. Make better dots.

So you're telling an entire league to "make better dots" as they play a winning, team game, as opposed to a team that sucks so bad that the kicker has 80% of their points?

Seems legit.

Fix ur builds

+1

Originally posted by coachingubigr
Fix ur builds

Coming from someone who has 5 level 79 dots, 0 of which are in WL. Got it.

I'm looking at the depth charts and nope, not on offense. Defense either.

Special Teams, would you look at that. That's where they are. Go figure.

+1

Originally posted by SciFi not Syfy
Can the kicker ever lose the kicker MVP if they win the offensive MVP? Seems like getting double credit.

Well it usually doesn't happen because kickers usually don't win the K/P MVP, you have the Punter from the shittiest team in the conference win it a lot of times cuz they put the ball about a million times.

Originally posted by DarkRogue
Well it usually doesn't happen because kickers usually don't win the K/P MVP, you have the Punter from the shittiest team in the conference win it a lot of times cuz they put the ball about a million times.

forgot about punters.

Were K/P ever part of the STMVP? I would think that they could figure out a formula to compare FG to TDs. So maybe a 50+ FG is worth a TD, 40+ half a TD, a XP worth 15 return yards. And lets face it, punters should never be MVP.

Originally posted by OneGiantLeap
Coming from someone who has 5 level 79 dots, 0 of which are in WL. Got it.

But I have an OMVP kicker.

So suck it