Warrior General Games

I am planning to retire one of these guys for flex and wanted to know how I did for their level.
Which of these two would you keep? Or do you suggest I just retire both and start from scratch again?

Lv 42 CB http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1208717

Strength: 38.21 (+1)
Blocking: 8
Speed: 100.87 (+26)
Tackling: 31.21
Agility: 74.87
Throwing: 8
Jumping: 61.87
Catching: 32.87
Stamina: 28.87
Carrying: 18.21
Vision: 69.87
Kicking: 9
Confidence: 30.21
Punting: 8

1-1-5-1-1
0-0-0-0-0

Ball Hawk 14
3rd Down Stopper 11


Lv 43 LOT http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1232726

Strength:102.41 (+26)
Blocking:78.41 (+4)
Speed:54
Tackling:26.72
Agility:74.41
Throwing:8
Jumping:10
Catching:9
Stamina:37.72
Carrying:8
Vision:51.41
Kicking:8
Confidence:46.41
Punting:8

3-2-6-2-5
0-0-0-0-0

Goal Line Blocker 7
Pass Blocker 11
Stone Wall 5

Definitely retire the OT. CB is salvageable, for AAA or lower. (agility, vision, stamina, confidence and strength are all problem areas, in that order.)