Warrior General Games

I have two MLBs, both of which I tried building in slightly different ways as strength based MLBs. I'm only keep one after this season. Who makes the cut?

Contestant #1 (level 21)
Physical Attributes
Strength: 63.6
Speed: 42 (+12)
Agility: 67.6 (+6)
Jumping: 15
Stamina: 19.6
Vision: 26.6
Confidence: 26.6

Football Skills
Blocking: 15
Catching: 15
Tackling: 50.6
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 8
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

Contestant #2 (level 22)

Physical Attributes
Strength: 71.85
Speed: 37.19 (+12)
Agility: 63.85 (+6)
Jumping: 15.19
Stamina: 22.85
Vision: 20.85
Confidence: 20.85

Football Skills
Blocking: 15.19
Catching: 15.19
Tackling: 50.85
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 8
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8

I'm not an expert, but I'd say keep the #1