Warrior General Games

Who is a better college QB, and who projects to the NFL better out of the two?

For those of you who don't know, Nate Davis is the Ball St. QB who led his team to a 7-6 record in the MAC conference. Having 35 Total TDs to 6 INTs with a 50% completion percentage for the year

Tim Tebow had 55 Total TDs to 6 INTs with a 66% completion percentage leading his team to an 8-4 record in the SEC

Now you may ask why even ask this question, but there are two posters on the board who argue Nate Davis is a better QB, so I've done my arguing, now would just like to hear some other opinions.

since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method

TBH Florida should have been better than 8-4. But I'm not deciding.

Originally posted by lletsGoEers
since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

And yes I use stats, to back up my opinion, what else do you want me to use?

Originally posted by jad6175
Originally posted by lletsGoEers

since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

Matt Stafford > Tim Tebow

although i hate tim teabag he is a way better QB and stole the heisman away from McFadden

Originally posted by baseball52
Originally posted by jad6175

Originally posted by lletsGoEers


since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

Matt Stafford > Tim Tebow


dude why are you chiming in with this Stafford shit? nobody even mentioned his name

Originally posted by jad6175
Originally posted by lletsGoEers

since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

And yes I use stats, to back up my opinion, what else do you want me to use?



how about the talent around them, their mechanics, their maturity, their athleticism, or their accuracy and strength stats only proves he had a better year it in no way proves hes a better QB but you dont seem to understand that b/c espn.com isn't saying that for you

Originally posted by jad6175
Originally posted by baseball52

Originally posted by jad6175


Originally posted by lletsGoEers



since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

Matt Stafford > Tim Tebow


dude why are you chiming in with this Stafford shit? nobody even mentioned his name

He is better and will be better in the NFL. Non-biased opinion also, Notre Dame fan.

Originally posted by baseball52
Originally posted by jad6175

Originally posted by baseball52


Originally posted by jad6175



Originally posted by lletsGoEers




since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

Matt Stafford > Tim Tebow


dude why are you chiming in with this Stafford shit? nobody even mentioned his name

He is better and will be better in the NFL. Non-biased opinion also, Notre Dame fan.

ouch.....Notre Dame

Darron Thomas Oregon QB wins heisman next year

Originally posted by lletsGoEers
Originally posted by baseball52

Originally posted by jad6175


Originally posted by baseball52



Originally posted by jad6175




Originally posted by lletsGoEers





since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

Matt Stafford > Tim Tebow


dude why are you chiming in with this Stafford shit? nobody even mentioned his name

He is better and will be better in the NFL. Non-biased opinion also, Notre Dame fan.

ouch.....Notre Dame

lol. 11 National Championships, I have a commemoration for each one in my house.

ya but last year had to be brutal

Originally posted by lletsGoEers
Originally posted by jad6175

Originally posted by lletsGoEers


since the only comparison you have is stats ill have to say Graham Harrell (Texas Tech) or Colt Brennan (Hawaii) is better by using your method


my comparison is TIM TEBOW IS BETTER THAN NATE DAVIS and it's not even close, what are you not understanding about that?

And yes I use stats, to back up my opinion, what else do you want me to use?



how about the talent around them, their mechanics, their maturity, their athleticism, or their accuracy and strength stats only proves he had a better year it in no way proves hes a better QB but you dont seem to understand that b/c espn.com isn't saying that for you


I love when you post stuff like that, so everyone can read how stupid you sound saying Nate Davis has better mechanics, is more mature, is more athletic, has more accuracy and strength than Tim Tebow.

Originally posted by daleysmith45
Darron Thomas Oregon QB wins heisman next year

Nope, Matt Stafford, Knowshawn Moreno, or Chris Wells.