Warrior General Games

Im a copy cat, I know, for one of the most active leagues it would be a shame to not have a pro bowl voting. each owner gets one chance to vote. Please vote within your current conference. If you want to submit now thats fine but it is a little early to be settled on who has the best season.

Rules:
1) You can't vote for players on your team or your own player
2) You can only vote once
3) Voting will close once the final game of the season is completed.
4)2x CB means vote for 2 CB.



Official ballot: Please mention if this is a EAST conference or West Conference Ballot.

2x QB =
2x RB =
2x FB =
3x WR =
2x TE =
2x C =
2x OG =
2x OT =

2x DT =
2x DE =
3x LB =
2x CB =
2x Safeties =

1x K =
1x P =

1x KR =
1x PR =

Sounds cool but two things.

1.) Shouldn't voting be closed the day after the final games? That way we can see the whole season stats and have time to get our votes in.

2.) Why are we voting for back up QB, RB, FB, WR, TE, C but only starters at the other spots? I mean 11 defensive players make it but 17 offensive players go?

Originally posted by RichG
Sounds cool but two things.

1.) Shouldn't voting be closed the day after the final games? That way we can see the whole season stats and have time to get our votes in.

2.) Why are we voting for back up QB, RB, FB, WR, TE, C but only starters at the other spots? I mean 11 defensive players make it but 17 offensive players go?

No. I mean 2 spots for the two different Conferecnes.

AKA.

East Team has one RB West has one RB..

^

But that doesn't answer the question of why there are no backup positions being voted on for the defense.

You have 17 spots for the offense.
You have 11 spots for the defense.

Why the difference?

Originally posted by sully
But that doesn't answer the question of why there are no backup positions being voted on for the defense.

You have 17 spots for the offense.
You have 11 spots for the defense.

Why the difference?


My bads. I mean its two players per postion.

so we vote for players in our conference correct, just not our own players or team mates?

Originally posted by tciss
so we vote for players in our conference correct, just not our own players or team mates?

Right. It will be voted on at the end of the season.

How is this any different than this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=226977

...maybe I'm missing something?

Originally posted by Candyman
Originally posted by sully

But that doesn't answer the question of why there are no backup positions being voted on for the defense.

You have 17 spots for the offense.
You have 11 spots for the defense.

Why the difference?


My bads. I mean its two players per postion.

so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks

Originally posted by chiefsc
Originally posted by Candyman

Originally posted by sully


But that doesn't answer the question of why there are no backup positions being voted on for the defense.

You have 17 spots for the offense.
You have 11 spots for the defense.

Why the difference?


My bads. I mean its two players per postion.

so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks



Yeah.

Originally posted by Candyman
Originally posted by chiefsc


so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks



Yeah.



Does it really have to be that complicated? I mean how am I supposed to know who's been playing LG all year or LCB as opposed to RCB? I'm sure I'm not the only one that occasionally moves people around depending on the match up (or maybe I am???).

Why not make it simple 1 starter and 1 back up for each position?

2x QB =
2x RB =
2x FB =
3x WR =
2x TE =
2x C =
3x OG =
3x OT =

3x DT =
3x DE =
4x LB =
3x CB =
3x S (1 FS, 1 SS and 1 either) =

Offense is still a little more represented but at least it's close and you don't have to worry about who plays where just take the 4 best LBs, the 3 best OTs, etc. The more difficult you make this on people the less chance you have of people responding which only hurts the teams of the owners that do respond since we can't vote for our own players.

Originally posted by RichG
Originally posted by Candyman

Originally posted by chiefsc



so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks



Yeah.



Does it really have to be that complicated? I mean how am I supposed to know who's been playing LG all year or LCB as opposed to RCB? I'm sure I'm not the only one that occasionally moves people around depending on the match up (or maybe I am???).

Why not make it simple 1 starter and 1 back up for each position?

2x QB =
2x RB =
2x FB =
3x WR =
2x TE =
2x C =
3x OG =
3x OT =

3x DT =
3x DE =
4x LB =
3x CB =
3x S (1 FS, 1 SS and 1 either) =

Offense is still a little more represented but at least it's close and you don't have to worry about who plays where just take the 4 best LBs, the 3 best OTs, etc. The more difficult you make this on people the less chance you have of people responding which only hurts the teams of the owners that do respond since we can't vote for our own players.




Thats a soild list.

You should post it at the end of the season.

Originally posted by RichG
Originally posted by Candyman

Originally posted by chiefsc



so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks



Yeah.



Does it really have to be that complicated? I mean how am I supposed to know who's been playing LG all year or LCB as opposed to RCB? I'm sure I'm not the only one that occasionally moves people around depending on the match up (or maybe I am???).

Why not make it simple 1 starter and 1 back up for each position?

2x QB =
2x RB =
2x FB =
3x WR =
2x TE =
2x C =
3x OG =
3x OT =

3x DT =
3x DE =
4x LB =
3x CB =
3x S (1 FS, 1 SS and 1 either) =

Offense is still a little more represented but at least it's close and you don't have to worry about who plays where just take the 4 best LBs, the 3 best OTs, etc. The more difficult you make this on people the less chance you have of people responding which only hurts the teams of the owners that do respond since we can't vote for our own players.

the defense needs more love. The secondary is getting a major shaft by combining FS and SS.

You listed 8 OL (10 if you count TE) but only 6 DL.

Originally posted by chiefsc
Originally posted by RichG

Originally posted by Candyman


Originally posted by chiefsc




so two players per position...meaning 2 LDE and 2 RDE...and 2 LOLB, 2MLB and 2 ROLB...2 RCB and 2 LCB...along those lines?


thanks



Yeah.



Does it really have to be that complicated? I mean how am I supposed to know who's been playing LG all year or LCB as opposed to RCB? I'm sure I'm not the only one that occasionally moves people around depending on the match up (or maybe I am???).

Why not make it simple 1 starter and 1 back up for each position?

2x QB =
2x RB =
2x FB =
3x WR =
2x TE =
2x C =
3x OG =
3x OT =

3x DT =
3x DE =
4x LB =
3x CB =
3x S (1 FS, 1 SS and 1 either) =

Offense is still a little more represented but at least it's close and you don't have to worry about who plays where just take the 4 best LBs, the 3 best OTs, etc. The more difficult you make this on people the less chance you have of people responding which only hurts the teams of the owners that do respond since we can't vote for our own players.

the defense needs more love. The secondary is getting a major shaft by combining FS and SS.

You listed 8 OL (10 if you count TE) but only 6 DL.



Offense is simply more segmented then the defense is so if you want back ups included it's going to be uneven. Still it's closer than the original breakdown.

If you want to make it exactly even then let's just vote for 1 player at each position.


1x QB =
1x RB =
1x FB =
2x WR =
1x TE =
1x C =
2x OG =
2x OT =

2x DT =
2x DE =
3x LB =
2x CB =
1x FS =
1x SS =

There 11 on offense and 11 on defense.