Warrior General Games

Originally posted by Mob-6
If it is an incompletion shouldn't that mean it was on the QB? The drops should be on the WRs. It would help for evaluating who needs to improve.

Not necessarily. It shows as an incompletion if the WR doesn't have enough jumping, not a drop, so that's the WR's fault. Also doesn't take into account deflections, which could be from the WR bobbling or the QB not making a great throw, etc. Too many variables to just lay all incomps on the QB and all drops on the WR.

Originally posted by Dravz
Originally posted by Mob-6

If it is an incompletion shouldn't that mean it was on the QB? The drops should be on the WRs. It would help for evaluating who needs to improve.

Not necessarily. It shows as an incompletion if the WR doesn't have enough jumping, not a drop, so that's the WR's fault. Also doesn't take into account deflections, which could be from the WR bobbling or the QB not making a great throw, etc. Too many variables to just lay all incomps on the QB and all drops on the WR.

I see what you are saying, but if a ball is over the head of a WR that is the QB's fault. The WR shouldn't have to jump to get a ball in stride. I would agree with the bobbling, the WR should catch the ball, that should be a drop and on him, if the QB puts it in his hands, the WR should bring it in. I would like to see a better statistics recorder so you can figure out which guy needs to improve his stats. Is it the WR catching that leads to incompletions or the QBs accuracy? It would be a waste if both guys increased points to fix this if only one player needed to.