Hmm, after thinking some more I would go with number one. I have a back very similar who is just coming into his own. He has two break tackle pieces though.
This is where he is at level 51
Physical Attributes
Strength: 86.15 (+7)
Speed: 105.15 (+27)
Agility: 61.15
Jumping: 26.23
Stamina: 44.23
Vision: 40.15
Confidence: 42.15
Football Skills
Blocking: 19.23 (+2)
Catching: 20.23
Tackling: 8
Throwing: 17.23
Carrying: 64.15
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8
Plus power back SA's.
This is where he is at level 51
Physical Attributes
Strength: 86.15 (+7)
Speed: 105.15 (+27)
Agility: 61.15
Jumping: 26.23
Stamina: 44.23
Vision: 40.15
Confidence: 42.15
Football Skills
Blocking: 19.23 (+2)
Catching: 20.23
Tackling: 8
Throwing: 17.23
Carrying: 64.15
Kicking: 8
Punting: 8
Plus power back SA's.




). Quick Feet with it's +30% for Spin Firing is pretty damn effective (plus the headfaking and juking bonuses even though your guy doesn't have a lot invested there). You don't need a lot of agility for Spin to fire in my experience so I don't think you're missing out much with only 72.8 agility.
























