User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Position Talk > WR Club > "One handed catch" VA
Dudly
offline
Link
 
I roled it for my TE and am not familiar with it, you all see much value to it?

If so, is it mainly on deeper passes or do any possesion recievers see it activate much for passes under 10 yards?
 
Tapout88
offline
Link
 
I have 2 1 Handed Catch AQs on my WR, its the Last SA on a Tree so I hope its good
 
jewness
offline
Link
 
i have aeq for it on my wr. most ppl view it negatively because its pretty much never fired...for anybody lol im wondering if theres any relation to confidence. like would it be dependent on confidence to fire more so then most ppl usually think? if anybodies got 60 conf. with 10 in 1 handed catch let me know if it fires lol
 
Dudly
offline
Link
 
thanks for the info guys, helps quite a bit, not having a WR I'm not familiar with it at all.

My guess would be that jewness is on to something with the importance of confidence to "one handed catch" but then again it might just be broken.

Bummer about it not firing very often, when it does have you all noticed if it's mainly on short or long passes?
 
Djinnt
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't get the AEQ.
 
jewness
offline
Link
 
yeah ive NEVER seen.it fire. its a shame too because it should go off atleast once every two or three games... would make it useful.
 
zhaoyun707
offline
Link
 
I think it only activates on "Bad Throw Lob Passes"
 
Tapout88
offline
Link
 
does it come up on the PBP?
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tapout88
does it come up on the PBP?


No.
 
Dudly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wlarson
Originally posted by Tapout88

does it come up on the PBP?


No.


really? that blows.
 
jewness
offline
Link
 
its supposed too...it just never happens. honestly i think it would be better if it went off once twice a game and they were still dropped so you atleast know it works...but yeah it should show up in pbp. far as i heard it does.
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jewness
its supposed too...it just never happens. honestly i think it would be better if it went off once twice a game and they were still dropped so you atleast know it works...but yeah it should show up in pbp. far as i heard it does.


I am about 99% positive that only diving catches and jumping catches show up in the pbp. Bort never added in 1 handed catches nor did he ever say he did.....

I assume it helps, though I have no idea how much so. I wish I could be more helpful. The people who say "its crap because I've never seen it fire" was way way off base though imo...
 
jewness
offline
Link
 
how is it not crap if nobody can seem to find a moment where it may have even happened?
 
WiSeIVIaN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jewness
how is it not crap if nobody can seem to find a moment where it may have even happened?


Grr... Because if it doesn't show up in the play-by-play text, there is absolutely no way of knowing how effective it is, so to auto-judge it crap is a bit retarded... Its kinda like you calling field general crap simple because you don't understand it...

Tbqh, I can find you 100's of moments for every WR where it "may" have happened, fwiw...
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.