Originally posted by tihan mannonen
invite please
sorry so late, but sent out. GOD BLESS
invite please
sorry so late, but sent out. GOD BLESS
Forum > Private Forum Announcements > CHRISTIAN PLAYERS OF GLB FORUM IS NOW OPEN
limburger
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
The real question is can God microwave a burrito a so hot that even he cannot eat it?
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
The real question is can God microwave a burrito a so hot that even he cannot eat it?
tyrell2110
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
No because there is no stone he can't lift
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
No because there is no stone he can't lift
Jagsfan2010
offline
offline
God Bless all of you guyz......sniff..sniff..its soo emotional.
Ok cheesy cracks aside invite plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
plz with holy water on top.
Ok cheesy cracks aside invite plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
plz with holy water on top.
BigBL87
offline
offline
Originally posted by limburger
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
The real question is can God microwave a burrito a so hot that even he cannot eat it?
The real question is can someone come up with a logical argument for this that doesn't contain a logical fallacy?
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
The real question is can God microwave a burrito a so hot that even he cannot eat it?
The real question is can someone come up with a logical argument for this that doesn't contain a logical fallacy?
Edited by BigBL87 on May 18, 2009 02:06:03
Paladin58
offline
offline
Originally posted by tyrell2110
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
No because there is no stone he can't lift
Then he isn't omnipotent. A divinity paradox.
But hey, if you guys want to believe what you do, i won't stop you. And, no problem in advance for the bump.
Originally posted by Rogers
If god can do anything, can he create a stone so heavy he cannot lift it?
Or a forum so complex he cannot understand it...
Think about that for a bit.
No because there is no stone he can't lift
Then he isn't omnipotent. A divinity paradox.
But hey, if you guys want to believe what you do, i won't stop you. And, no problem in advance for the bump.
Buzz42day
offline
offline
This question has a fundamental assumption that is not stated in the question:
God can do anything that is Possible. This statement must logically be intrinsically true because: Even God can't do something that is not possible to be done. The "Stone Question" is logically impossible to ask, as it logically translates to: Can God do something that is not possible?
The answer must be No, as by definition something that "can not be done" can not be done. This is equivalent to saying something like "Can God make Zero equal One?" Logically and mathematically, this is impossible, as by definition zero and one (and all discrete numbers) by definition can not have the same value as another discrete number.
Therefore, the answer to the question is: (Drum Roll, please) No. God can not make a stone so heavy that He can not lift it. Because if God is all-powerful (meaning that he can do anything that is possible to be done) it is impossible for Him to create a stone that He could not lift, because it is not possible to do so.
God can do anything that is Possible. This statement must logically be intrinsically true because: Even God can't do something that is not possible to be done. The "Stone Question" is logically impossible to ask, as it logically translates to: Can God do something that is not possible?
The answer must be No, as by definition something that "can not be done" can not be done. This is equivalent to saying something like "Can God make Zero equal One?" Logically and mathematically, this is impossible, as by definition zero and one (and all discrete numbers) by definition can not have the same value as another discrete number.
Therefore, the answer to the question is: (Drum Roll, please) No. God can not make a stone so heavy that He can not lift it. Because if God is all-powerful (meaning that he can do anything that is possible to be done) it is impossible for Him to create a stone that He could not lift, because it is not possible to do so.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
