Warrior General Games

Originally posted by Thundercat_12
Ryan is the next 2 jump into the tier 1 group

Newton yes I admit Iwas a huge freakn doubter at first but can't deny he's done some good thingswith what he has

Stafford yes I know the lions all they do is pass but with megatron stafford is solid. Now I want 2 see teams double team man coverage calvin for an ENTIRE game and see what the lions do

Lastly name me better QBs that belong in tier 2 I can't make an argument for any not listed

its not about who else belongs in tier 2

its who DOESNT

Originally posted by Thundercat_12
Ryan is the next 2 jump into the tier 1 group




Originally posted by Thundercat_12
Newton yes I admit Iwas a huge freakn doubter at first but can't deny he's done some good thingswith what he has


He hasn't even been in the league for 3 seasons.

Originally posted by Thundercat_12
Lastly name me better QBs that belong in tier 2 I can't make an argument for any not listed

Carson Palmer?
Flacco (bit of a let down this season)?
Schaub?
Alex Smith?

Originally posted by BagO'Chips
Originally posted by Thundercat_12

Ryan is the next 2 jump into the tier 1 group




Originally posted by Thundercat_12

Newton yes I admit Iwas a huge freakn doubter at first but can't deny he's done some good thingswith what he has


He hasn't even been in the league for 3 seasons.

Originally posted by Thundercat_12

Lastly name me better QBs that belong in tier 2 I can't make an argument for any not listed

Carson Palmer?
Flacco (bit of a let down this season)?
Schaub?
Alex Smith?

wow - only Schaub can even be considered from the 4 you listed

Originally posted by reddogrw
wow - only Schaub can even be considered from the 4 you listed

This dude put Cam Newton in Tier 2 and had Matt Ryan over Manning and Roethlisberger.

And I think Smith could be a Tier 2 QB tbh.

Edit: Also, Palmer was a bit of a reach, Flacco is close to Tier 2.

Originally posted by reddogrw
wow - only Schaub can even be considered from the 4 you listed

Alex smith (who got the shaft during his injury) leads the nfl in passer rating, and belongs in tier 2 imo

Originally posted by Jay89
Alex smith (who got the shaft during his injury) leads the nfl in passer rating, and belongs in tier 2 imo

True but you can't make the list wearing a ballcap

Originally posted by Jay89
Alex smith (who got the shaft during his injury) leads the nfl in passer rating, and belongs in tier 2 imo

smith isnt tier 2 lol

Originally posted by logwwe
nou

Sit.

Stay...

Troll over!

Good boy...

Originally posted by Thundercat_12
Thank you....quincy carter vinny and bledsoe all sucked

Romo is a low end 2nd tier QB

TIER 1
P. Manning
Brady
Rodgers
Brees

TIER 2
Ryan
E. Manning - No
Big Ben
Newton - No
Romo - No
Stafford - No


Romo is not a 2d tier QB and is not better than Schaub, Rivers, Dalton, Griffin, Luck and I might even through Wilson in that group or not.

Romo is on par with Stafford, E Manning, and Bradford and probably Newton when he tries. So throw Romo in tier 3 and not long for Dallas as he and Garrett are likely to get the boot.

Then Dallas has not won an important and meaningful game in how many seasons, so doubtful they are going to beat the Redskins. Two or three bad coaching calls WILL do them in. Too much history to support that.

Are u fuckn kidding me with Rivers are you watchn the same games

Rivers is lucky to be a tier 4 QB

Schaub and dalton and high end 3rd tier. Griffin Luck and Wilson low end 3rd tier need more than 1 season to be better than an avg QB

But the question also remains, when is the last time the Redskins have won a meaningful football game. It's been longer even than Dallas. Something has got to give.

Originally posted by BagO'Chips
This dude had Matt Ryan over Manning

sounds correct

Pallow said he would change mcBriars name if Dallas loses. Thread is win

Originally posted by Pallow
If he doesn't request it, I will make it happen.

I take back my most recent thread in the mod forum.

Originally posted by InRomoWeTrust
I take back my most recent thread in the mod forum.

Lol
The stage is set