Originally posted by RayRay99
If he is such a winner, why did he get benched like 3 times in Tennessee and fail to beat out Kerry Collins? Why is it he didn't get a starting gig on another team when he was cut by the "shitty head coach" that happens to be one of the most respected in football? Surely if he is such a winner and All-everything player he would have got a sniff from teams like Washington, Miami, or Cincinnati? It is because he is a head case. What other quality QBs do you know of who go missing and have team officials have the police involved to find him or get pissy and throw their gear in the stands or are constantly dogged by rumblings of their lack of work ethic and immaturity? Combined with the fact he is a moron who scored a 6 on the Wonderlic, and you have an individual who is blessed with a lot of athletic ability, and is wasting it trying to be a QB when he would likely be more effective as a WR.
Once again an aggie puts forth fiction like fact. He didn't get cut by one of the most respected head coaches, he got cut by the same owner who sent that head coach to the unemployment line. Adams wanted a clean break with the old regime and did that by getting rid of the coach and the player who caused poor media coverage of the franchise.
As for getting sniffs from other teams, you don't know what interest he received. You assume because he took a place backing up VY that he didn't have offers from other organizations. VY himself said he had other interest but chose Philly because he felt it would be the best place for him to improve as a QB. Maybe, just maybe he wanted to go to a good franchise and learn instead of go to another shitty franchise and be the scapegoat for a poor organization.
6 on the Wolderlic? This is a perfect example of the aggie mindset. Everyone else knows that the 6 was due to an error scoring the test, but you cling to the idea that he actually made a 6. You really do live in your own little cult inspired world.
Originally posted by RayRay99
Taking out the guys who barely played (making those stats irrelevant), I see very little similarity between the stats above and VY's.
Young: 15 GMs, 51.5%, 12, 13
And now look at his outstanding career in which he has won ROY and 2 Pro Bowl selections.
Through 5 years of playing he is averaging.....wait for it.....
150 passing yards a game
Combined with his EXCELLENT 42/42 TD/Int ratio and 57% completion percentage and career QB rating of 75.7 I am sure he could retire now and be a surefire HOFer.
Again















I'd be happy for you to compare his stats versus other 5th year QBs in the league. I'd also love for you to compare his most reason season to the seasons of the other top QBs in the league. He's improved greatly each season he's played, and last season was performing as a top 5 QB in the league prior to getting injured.
Originally posted by RayRay99
To be fair, he took them from 0-6 to 5-6 before finishing 8-8.
During that span, the defense went from giving up 33 ppg to 20.4 ppg
Chris Johnson went from averaging 102 ypg to 141 ypg
Passing yards only went from 179 ypc to 190 ypc. (If you throw out the Patriots debacle where VY had 0 yds and Collins had -7, Collins was actually averaging 214 to VY's 190).
Looks to me an improved defense and running game played a much more pivotal role than VY stepping in.
So the only change to the team was a change in QB, but it had nothing to do with any of those improvements. The defense just magically got much better, CJ just randomly learned how to run, and the team magically started scoring more. The change in performance between a VY lead offense and a Collins lead offense has been discussed ad nauseam, so I won't go there, but that would prove you to be an idiot as well.
If he is such a winner, why did he get benched like 3 times in Tennessee and fail to beat out Kerry Collins? Why is it he didn't get a starting gig on another team when he was cut by the "shitty head coach" that happens to be one of the most respected in football? Surely if he is such a winner and All-everything player he would have got a sniff from teams like Washington, Miami, or Cincinnati? It is because he is a head case. What other quality QBs do you know of who go missing and have team officials have the police involved to find him or get pissy and throw their gear in the stands or are constantly dogged by rumblings of their lack of work ethic and immaturity? Combined with the fact he is a moron who scored a 6 on the Wonderlic, and you have an individual who is blessed with a lot of athletic ability, and is wasting it trying to be a QB when he would likely be more effective as a WR.
Once again an aggie puts forth fiction like fact. He didn't get cut by one of the most respected head coaches, he got cut by the same owner who sent that head coach to the unemployment line. Adams wanted a clean break with the old regime and did that by getting rid of the coach and the player who caused poor media coverage of the franchise.
As for getting sniffs from other teams, you don't know what interest he received. You assume because he took a place backing up VY that he didn't have offers from other organizations. VY himself said he had other interest but chose Philly because he felt it would be the best place for him to improve as a QB. Maybe, just maybe he wanted to go to a good franchise and learn instead of go to another shitty franchise and be the scapegoat for a poor organization.
6 on the Wolderlic? This is a perfect example of the aggie mindset. Everyone else knows that the 6 was due to an error scoring the test, but you cling to the idea that he actually made a 6. You really do live in your own little cult inspired world.
Originally posted by RayRay99
Taking out the guys who barely played (making those stats irrelevant), I see very little similarity between the stats above and VY's.
Young: 15 GMs, 51.5%, 12, 13
And now look at his outstanding career in which he has won ROY and 2 Pro Bowl selections.
Through 5 years of playing he is averaging.....wait for it.....
150 passing yards a game
Combined with his EXCELLENT 42/42 TD/Int ratio and 57% completion percentage and career QB rating of 75.7 I am sure he could retire now and be a surefire HOFer.
Again















I'd be happy for you to compare his stats versus other 5th year QBs in the league. I'd also love for you to compare his most reason season to the seasons of the other top QBs in the league. He's improved greatly each season he's played, and last season was performing as a top 5 QB in the league prior to getting injured.
Originally posted by RayRay99
To be fair, he took them from 0-6 to 5-6 before finishing 8-8.
During that span, the defense went from giving up 33 ppg to 20.4 ppg
Chris Johnson went from averaging 102 ypg to 141 ypg
Passing yards only went from 179 ypc to 190 ypc. (If you throw out the Patriots debacle where VY had 0 yds and Collins had -7, Collins was actually averaging 214 to VY's 190).
Looks to me an improved defense and running game played a much more pivotal role than VY stepping in.
So the only change to the team was a change in QB, but it had nothing to do with any of those improvements. The defense just magically got much better, CJ just randomly learned how to run, and the team magically started scoring more. The change in performance between a VY lead offense and a Collins lead offense has been discussed ad nauseam, so I won't go there, but that would prove you to be an idiot as well.





























