Hi!
I used to play this game a LOT!! I have referred dozens of friends to play and stopped playing over a year ago. I decided to check it out recently, because I'm having withdraws from NFL and NCAA football offseason. The NFL draft is coming up, so that helps, but still, I liked this game.
The reason I stopped playing was that my players dropped skill points too quickly as they aged. It made it so that once I finally had a player who was doing well in the higher leagues, he started to decline rapidly! By the time I was happy with a build, he had to be scrapped and start over. That is a DRAG!!
I'm sure there are hundreds of reasons for the downfall of the player base, but I definitely see the speed of player decline being one of them.
If players either did not decline, or declined at such a low pace that it was actually fun again, I'm sure people wouldn't just look at this game as a passing fad, but instead as an ongoing competitive game.
I'm sure many of you will just ignore the thoughts of people trying to help and claim they are merely, "whining," but for every "whiner" there are 100 people who just quit without a word. Think about that.