-1
but +1
I have a reason for both
but +1
I have a reason for both
Forum > Suggestions > Average starting field position stat
Originally posted by dahman32
Both flyby "-1 and +1" and vague, otherwise neither have valid concerns....
pot meet kettle
Both flyby "-1 and +1" and vague, otherwise neither have valid concerns....
pot meet kettle
BadgerPhil
offline
offline
Originally posted by The Avenger
Edited by The Avenger on Oct 4, 2013 21:47:56
Edited by The Avenger on Oct 4, 2013 21:14:19
-1 > because the box score in GLB has at least 2-3 things that need far more attention then the avg starting position stat. How many read the paper on a monday morning after the NFL games are listed and want to know the avg starting position in the box score? or even on NFL.com boxscores for avg starting position?
Thats why Phil, thats why.
See, that's all I was asking for. I know you are good at the game, so I might value your opinion. Believe it or not. I'd agree that there are certainly more important stats that need to be implemented. Though "in my opinion" that is not a good reason to '-1' an idea.
As to the Monday Morning Paper comment, I'd assume if the only place a ST Coordinator could get his information to do his job or at least assist him in doing his job, he'd want it in there. Joe Blow probably doesn't care, but that doesn't mean everybody doesn't care.
But if your '-1' is purely because there are more important suggestions for box scores and/or stats from games, I can respect that. I don't agree, that it is a valid reason to '-1' a suggestion. But that is purely my opinion.
Edited by The Avenger on Oct 4, 2013 21:47:56
Edited by The Avenger on Oct 4, 2013 21:14:19
-1 > because the box score in GLB has at least 2-3 things that need far more attention then the avg starting position stat. How many read the paper on a monday morning after the NFL games are listed and want to know the avg starting position in the box score? or even on NFL.com boxscores for avg starting position?
Thats why Phil, thats why.
See, that's all I was asking for. I know you are good at the game, so I might value your opinion. Believe it or not. I'd agree that there are certainly more important stats that need to be implemented. Though "in my opinion" that is not a good reason to '-1' an idea.
As to the Monday Morning Paper comment, I'd assume if the only place a ST Coordinator could get his information to do his job or at least assist him in doing his job, he'd want it in there. Joe Blow probably doesn't care, but that doesn't mean everybody doesn't care.
But if your '-1' is purely because there are more important suggestions for box scores and/or stats from games, I can respect that. I don't agree, that it is a valid reason to '-1' a suggestion. But that is purely my opinion.
BadgerPhil
offline
offline
Originally posted by dahman32
Both flyby "-1 and +1" and vague, otherwise neither have valid concerns....
pot meet kettle
Not exactly I am supporting the suggestion as presented. Meaning I don't disagree with any part. If I did, I would explain what I did not like or suggest a change/addition. So there is nothing vague about it. That's how I've always seen a '+1'.
A '-1' has no explanation built into it, like a '+1' does.
I will be honest and say the only reason I brought it up, was I don't think Avenger cares one way or the other about the suggestion. It was just a safe way for him to stick it to erza. Just my opinion, but I'd be willing to bet if im4ut999 suggested it would either get no response from Avenger or a '+1'.
Both flyby "-1 and +1" and vague, otherwise neither have valid concerns....
pot meet kettle
Not exactly I am supporting the suggestion as presented. Meaning I don't disagree with any part. If I did, I would explain what I did not like or suggest a change/addition. So there is nothing vague about it. That's how I've always seen a '+1'.
A '-1' has no explanation built into it, like a '+1' does.
I will be honest and say the only reason I brought it up, was I don't think Avenger cares one way or the other about the suggestion. It was just a safe way for him to stick it to erza. Just my opinion, but I'd be willing to bet if im4ut999 suggested it would either get no response from Avenger or a '+1'.
Maybe too much explanation, Phil. I kinda got lost in it all. Still, I've had plenty of time to consider adding stats to the game. It boils down to 2 categories:
#1, Stats which are useful to teams (coaches and the like) and,
#2, Stats which are simply nice to have available for viewing.
I've long wished for nothing more than an ability for the USERS to choose which stats are listed for teams and for individual dots. This ability would allow customization that not only would enhance the interface between user and game... but would also allow coaches to decide which stats are important for THEM to keep track of for their own purposes. Static stats, such as we have now, really suck. I've built (and currently own) several STOP players whose stats do NOT even come CLOSE to reflecting what they do on the field. Sure, I can go to the team stat page and compile my own stats from there... but should I really HAVE to? As for the OP's suggestion, I'm personally a -1 because that particular stat has no appeal to me. But I can see where it might appeal to others. So, since ALL stats are compiled during the games played, why not let us user choose which are important to us and select them for our viewing pleasure rather than this constant creation of threads asking for stats and stats and stats and stats. Now THAT suggestion, I am WAY +1 for.
#1, Stats which are useful to teams (coaches and the like) and,
#2, Stats which are simply nice to have available for viewing.
I've long wished for nothing more than an ability for the USERS to choose which stats are listed for teams and for individual dots. This ability would allow customization that not only would enhance the interface between user and game... but would also allow coaches to decide which stats are important for THEM to keep track of for their own purposes. Static stats, such as we have now, really suck. I've built (and currently own) several STOP players whose stats do NOT even come CLOSE to reflecting what they do on the field. Sure, I can go to the team stat page and compile my own stats from there... but should I really HAVE to? As for the OP's suggestion, I'm personally a -1 because that particular stat has no appeal to me. But I can see where it might appeal to others. So, since ALL stats are compiled during the games played, why not let us user choose which are important to us and select them for our viewing pleasure rather than this constant creation of threads asking for stats and stats and stats and stats. Now THAT suggestion, I am WAY +1 for.
dahman32
offline
offline
Originally posted by BadgerPhil
Not exactly I am supporting the suggestion as presented. Meaning I don't disagree with any part. If I did, I would explain what I did not like or suggest a change/addition. So there is nothing vague about it. That's how I've always seen a '+1'.
A '-1' has no explanation built into it, like a '+1' does.
I will be honest and say the only reason I brought it up, was I don't think Avenger cares one way or the other about the suggestion. It was just a safe way for him to stick it to erza. Just my opinion, but I'd be willing to bet if im4ut999 suggested it would either get no response from Avenger or a '+1'.
If someone doesn't care for it that is for them to not care for it
Like asking someone coming out of a voting booth why they voted down an amendment, not much tact especially if one is an official. Just saying
Why does it matter what you think someone else thinks if the suggestions are for others to ...
oh nevermind, this is going to NGTH anyway... moving along lol
/thread or move to Epic
Not exactly I am supporting the suggestion as presented. Meaning I don't disagree with any part. If I did, I would explain what I did not like or suggest a change/addition. So there is nothing vague about it. That's how I've always seen a '+1'.
A '-1' has no explanation built into it, like a '+1' does.
I will be honest and say the only reason I brought it up, was I don't think Avenger cares one way or the other about the suggestion. It was just a safe way for him to stick it to erza. Just my opinion, but I'd be willing to bet if im4ut999 suggested it would either get no response from Avenger or a '+1'.
If someone doesn't care for it that is for them to not care for it
Like asking someone coming out of a voting booth why they voted down an amendment, not much tact especially if one is an official. Just saying
Why does it matter what you think someone else thinks if the suggestions are for others to ...
oh nevermind, this is going to NGTH anyway... moving along lol
/thread or move to Epic
BadgerPhil
offline
offline
Originally posted by dahman32
If someone doesn't care for it that is for them to not care for it
Like asking someone coming out of a voting booth why they voted down an amendment, not much tact especially if one is an official. Just saying
Why does it matter what you think someone else thinks if the suggestions are for others to ...
oh nevermind, this is going to NGTH anyway... moving along lol
/thread or move to Epic
It doesn't matter, just my opinion, and like I said... normally I don't say anything. Just the fact that I know Avenger could give two shits one way or the other about the suggestion, he' making a statement about the OP. Anybody else as the OP and he doesn't stop by and give his -1. Have you seen him comment on any other suggestion? He broke no rules, but I am free to share my opinion, am I not?
For somebody that likes to share their opinion a lot, you are awfully sensitive to the opinions of others.
BTW, so we are clear... these are my opinions, not the opinions of GLB. Mine as a paying user of the game just like you.
If someone doesn't care for it that is for them to not care for it
Like asking someone coming out of a voting booth why they voted down an amendment, not much tact especially if one is an official. Just saying
Why does it matter what you think someone else thinks if the suggestions are for others to ...
oh nevermind, this is going to NGTH anyway... moving along lol
/thread or move to Epic
It doesn't matter, just my opinion, and like I said... normally I don't say anything. Just the fact that I know Avenger could give two shits one way or the other about the suggestion, he' making a statement about the OP. Anybody else as the OP and he doesn't stop by and give his -1. Have you seen him comment on any other suggestion? He broke no rules, but I am free to share my opinion, am I not?
For somebody that likes to share their opinion a lot, you are awfully sensitive to the opinions of others.
BTW, so we are clear... these are my opinions, not the opinions of GLB. Mine as a paying user of the game just like you.
dahman32
offline
offline
Originally posted by BadgerPhil
It doesn't matter, just my opinion, and like I said... normally I don't say anything. Just the fact that I know Avenger could give two shits one way or the other about the suggestion, he' making a statement about the OP. Anybody else as the OP and he doesn't stop by and give his -1. Have you seen him comment on any other suggestion? He broke no rules, but I am free to share my opinion, am I not?
For somebody that likes to share their opinion a lot, you are awfully sensitive to the opinions of others.
BTW, so we are clear... these are my opinions, not the opinions of GLB. Mine as a paying user of the game just like you.
-1
No explanation needed
now
It doesn't matter, just my opinion, and like I said... normally I don't say anything. Just the fact that I know Avenger could give two shits one way or the other about the suggestion, he' making a statement about the OP. Anybody else as the OP and he doesn't stop by and give his -1. Have you seen him comment on any other suggestion? He broke no rules, but I am free to share my opinion, am I not?
For somebody that likes to share their opinion a lot, you are awfully sensitive to the opinions of others.
BTW, so we are clear... these are my opinions, not the opinions of GLB. Mine as a paying user of the game just like you.
-1
No explanation needed
now
Edited by dahman32 on Oct 6, 2013 09:57:04
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
