There would be pass interference on every play, IMO.
Forum > Suggestions > Remove False Start/Encroachment or add all of the other football penalties
Originally posted by yello1
Make penalties 100% player tactic based, then add them all.
Competitiveness Tactic
Low end halves effect morale effect of negative morale events and the chance of being called for a penalty
High end doubles the effect of positive morale events and increases by 50% the chance of being called for a penalty
The Penalties that are effected are - False Start and Encroachment
At high end positive settings there is also a potential of being called for a Personal Foul
Grabbing Tactic
Low End Reduces the chance of making a tackle, holding a block, breaking a block, deflecting a pass, deflecting an interception, and the chance of being called for a penalty
High End Increases the chance of making a tackle, breaking a block, avoiding a pass deflection, deflecting a pass or interception, and the chance of being called for a penalty.
The Penalties that are effected are - Holding and Illegal Use of the Hands
At high end positive settings (increasingly high after say +50 there is also a potential of being called for Face Mask and Offensive or Defensive Pass Interference
By the way, the notion he is that if you set it to -100 you will NOT get a penalty called. +100 it happens more often but not annoyingly so. Figure if your player has both settings at +100 you will get about one penalty a game, which is NFL record level penalty making.
That said the bonuses obtained should be scaled accordingly. Nothing great for that one penalty a game, nothing too much given up to avoid penalties either.
Make penalties 100% player tactic based, then add them all.
Competitiveness Tactic
Low end halves effect morale effect of negative morale events and the chance of being called for a penalty
High end doubles the effect of positive morale events and increases by 50% the chance of being called for a penalty
The Penalties that are effected are - False Start and Encroachment
At high end positive settings there is also a potential of being called for a Personal Foul
Grabbing Tactic
Low End Reduces the chance of making a tackle, holding a block, breaking a block, deflecting a pass, deflecting an interception, and the chance of being called for a penalty
High End Increases the chance of making a tackle, breaking a block, avoiding a pass deflection, deflecting a pass or interception, and the chance of being called for a penalty.
The Penalties that are effected are - Holding and Illegal Use of the Hands
At high end positive settings (increasingly high after say +50 there is also a potential of being called for Face Mask and Offensive or Defensive Pass Interference
By the way, the notion he is that if you set it to -100 you will NOT get a penalty called. +100 it happens more often but not annoyingly so. Figure if your player has both settings at +100 you will get about one penalty a game, which is NFL record level penalty making.
That said the bonuses obtained should be scaled accordingly. Nothing great for that one penalty a game, nothing too much given up to avoid penalties either.
PatrickStump
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
So penalize lineman and nobody else? That makes sense how?
People would bitch cause their dot committed a penalty? Than they should fix their builds...
It penalizes both teams linemen, not just one. Remember, this isn't the NFL.
So penalize lineman and nobody else? That makes sense how?
People would bitch cause their dot committed a penalty? Than they should fix their builds...
It penalizes both teams linemen, not just one. Remember, this isn't the NFL.
_OSIRIS_
offline
offline
Originally posted by yello1
Yeah I have to agree. Just had my pee wee team called for five or six false starts in our playoff game which we lost by seven points. Very frustrating. And its not like I didn't put a few points into vision along the way either.
We got our usual 10 false starts. That is 10 in 11 drives. I'm going to have to change my AI up because it changes everything. My dots have 20+vision, confidence, and stamina. Maybe jumping or punting would help.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1995307
Yeah I have to agree. Just had my pee wee team called for five or six false starts in our playoff game which we lost by seven points. Very frustrating. And its not like I didn't put a few points into vision along the way either.
We got our usual 10 false starts. That is 10 in 11 drives. I'm going to have to change my AI up because it changes everything. My dots have 20+vision, confidence, and stamina. Maybe jumping or punting would help.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1995307
_OSIRIS_
offline
offline
Originally posted by LordEvil
It's the same as getting false starts on every drive in a tough game. What are the odds are you are going to overcome them? Do away with them already!
It's the same as getting false starts on every drive in a tough game. What are the odds are you are going to overcome them? Do away with them already!
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by PatrickStump
Originally posted by Robbnva
So penalize lineman and nobody else? That makes sense how?
People would bitch cause their dot committed a penalty? Than they should fix their builds...
It penalizes both teams linemen, not just one. Remember, this isn't the NFL.
false starts happen way more than encroachment.
and yes this isn't the nfl, it's retarded people keep throwing this out there when most of the players join this site came because they are football fans...
add to that, the polls way back when suggested people wanted some what realistic stats, 10 fals starts almost every game isn't realistic.
Originally posted by Robbnva
So penalize lineman and nobody else? That makes sense how?
People would bitch cause their dot committed a penalty? Than they should fix their builds...
It penalizes both teams linemen, not just one. Remember, this isn't the NFL.
false starts happen way more than encroachment.
and yes this isn't the nfl, it's retarded people keep throwing this out there when most of the players join this site came because they are football fans...
add to that, the polls way back when suggested people wanted some what realistic stats, 10 fals starts almost every game isn't realistic.
numone
offline
offline
the linemen aren't really getting penalized, the whole team is. sure it's called on one particular dot, but the team gains or loses the yard. to say a particular position is being punished is very misleading. It's fine as is imo.
and this suggestion needs another
imo
and this suggestion needs another
imoRobbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by numone
the linemen aren't really getting penalized, the whole team is. sure it's called on one particular dot, but the team gains or loses the yard. to say a particular position is being punished is very misleading. It's fine as is imo.
and this suggestion needs another
imo
seriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?
the linemen aren't really getting penalized, the whole team is. sure it's called on one particular dot, but the team gains or loses the yard. to say a particular position is being punished is very misleading. It's fine as is imo.
and this suggestion needs another
imoseriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?

numone
offline
offline
Originally posted by Robbnva
seriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
seriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?

which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
Originally posted by numone
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
Mine was Pee Wee with five or six, playoff.
It needs to be tuned down. At least in pee wee.
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
Mine was Pee Wee with five or six, playoff.
It needs to be tuned down. At least in pee wee.
Originally posted by LordEvil
It's the same as getting false starts on every drive in a tough game. What are the odds are you are going to overcome them? Do away with them already!
I'm in agreement. All for getting rid of.... but not in favor of adding everything else. It's already rediculous enough with only two.
It's the same as getting false starts on every drive in a tough game. What are the odds are you are going to overcome them? Do away with them already!
I'm in agreement. All for getting rid of.... but not in favor of adding everything else. It's already rediculous enough with only two.
Robbnva
offline
offline
Originally posted by numone
Originally posted by Robbnva
seriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
why does everything have to do with just pro/wl? it affects every league
Originally posted by Robbnva
seriously? 10 false starts a game is fine?

which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
why does everything have to do with just pro/wl? it affects every league
_OSIRIS_
offline
offline
Originally posted by numone
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
Here was my playoff game. Just like all the others lately. I think I'm averaging 9 a game. I like to call risky plays on second and short but now when they fail I keep getting false starts on 3rd and 4 or 5 so I can't do that anymore. It just shouldn't be that way. So realistic.:/
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1995307&mode=pbp
which game you referring to? was it a pro/wl game?
Here was my playoff game. Just like all the others lately. I think I'm averaging 9 a game. I like to call risky plays on second and short but now when they fail I keep getting false starts on 3rd and 4 or 5 so I can't do that anymore. It just shouldn't be that way. So realistic.:/
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1995307&mode=pbp
dahman32
offline
offline
But the best are the back to back false starts, even the back to back to back false starts.
Baffling, but I guess that is how it is supposed to be.
Baffling, but I guess that is how it is supposed to be.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























