Originally posted by LeadUsNot
Originally posted by TaintStick
Nice write-up as always HB! I'm not particularly sold on bandar being better than us, but ya'll have actually played both of our teams when it counted, so I'll trust your judgement.... Gotta say though, I was hoping to see you categorize it similar to what Creeker did with his reviews, because I think there is a HUGE decline from the #3 to the #4 spot.......wait for it.....wait for it..............
I would however, have to put Semarang above the Tweetys, just off of the "what have you done for me lately" rule, and Semarang just absolutely DESTROYED teams in the playoffs, with a SIM that was not very friendly to their offensive scheme. Plus, we got the Tweety's Best DE in the offseason However, I would rank BOTH of those teams above Manilla, just on the fact tha Manilla has really struggled since coming up to the pro's(including playoffs has been 39-15 over the last 3 seasons)
You still feel that way Taint? Easily took care of the Garuda match ups without boosting
Heh...didn't think anything I said ever stuck with you LUN
I never put that much stock into preseason games....especially this season with what appears to be the most significant changes to the SIM since season 6. That being said, I think you had a good showing this preseason, as the games weren't even close. NOt having watched the games, i can't say if i should be impressed or not.
But, to my original point, I still think Semerang should be ranked above Manilla. Again, not putting much stock into the preseason, but they had a good showing as well, and coupled with last years performance, I still think they have a stronger team. Now the Tweety's are another story. I would have thought on talent alone they would have stayed in more of the games in the preseason, but again, I don't know what the hell there tactics for the games were. So for now, yes, i still feel the same way....but I'm definitely not as confident in my statements.
Originally posted by TaintStick
Nice write-up as always HB! I'm not particularly sold on bandar being better than us, but ya'll have actually played both of our teams when it counted, so I'll trust your judgement.... Gotta say though, I was hoping to see you categorize it similar to what Creeker did with his reviews, because I think there is a HUGE decline from the #3 to the #4 spot.......wait for it.....wait for it..............
I would however, have to put Semarang above the Tweetys, just off of the "what have you done for me lately" rule, and Semarang just absolutely DESTROYED teams in the playoffs, with a SIM that was not very friendly to their offensive scheme. Plus, we got the Tweety's Best DE in the offseason
However, I would rank BOTH of those teams above Manilla, just on the fact tha Manilla has really struggled since coming up to the pro's(including playoffs has been 39-15 over the last 3 seasons)You still feel that way Taint? Easily took care of the Garuda match ups without boosting
Heh...didn't think anything I said ever stuck with you LUN
I never put that much stock into preseason games....especially this season with what appears to be the most significant changes to the SIM since season 6. That being said, I think you had a good showing this preseason, as the games weren't even close. NOt having watched the games, i can't say if i should be impressed or not.
But, to my original point, I still think Semerang should be ranked above Manilla. Again, not putting much stock into the preseason, but they had a good showing as well, and coupled with last years performance, I still think they have a stronger team. Now the Tweety's are another story. I would have thought on talent alone they would have stayed in more of the games in the preseason, but again, I don't know what the hell there tactics for the games were. So for now, yes, i still feel the same way....but I'm definitely not as confident in my statements.
