Warrior General Games

Originally posted by zujecuho
i'm no owner... but

QB = Colbee Pardee, Brady Anderson
HB = Toe Blake, Borat
FB = Mikhail Hunt, Twoday Beard
WR = Devlin, Yoda, Zed, Peter Steel
TE = Elbright, Sampleton
S = Ray Odoms
CB = Corey Webby
KR = Ippon Seionage
PR = Jerome Bettis



How on earth can you not select Wayne at QB? 24 TD's, 2 Int., the highest gain per passing play and completion. Plus he is on a majority running team. Trust me if we wanted hit to be leading in yardage he would be after tonights game. But I think that is all you looked at.

I am in agreement with the voting but instead of owners only, it should be a limited # of people per team. Like 2 voters per team or something like that.

Originally posted by DVSmith30
Originally posted by zujecuho

i'm no owner... but

QB = Colbee Pardee, Brady Anderson
HB = Toe Blake, Borat
FB = Mikhail Hunt, Twoday Beard
WR = Devlin, Yoda, Zed, Peter Steel
TE = Elbright, Sampleton
S = Ray Odoms
CB = Corey Webby
KR = Ippon Seionage
PR = Jerome Bettis



How on earth can you not select Wayne at QB? 24 TD's, 2 Int., the highest gain per passing play and completion. Plus he is on a majority running team. Trust me if we wanted hit to be leading in yardage he would be after tonights game. But I think that is all you looked at.

I am in agreement with the voting but instead of owners only, it should be a limited # of people per team. Like 2 voters per team or something like that.


Let the man vote for who he wants.

DVSmith,

Just to set the record straight, Donnie Norris has the more Yards per Attempt and more yards per completion than Wayne. He also has a higher completion percentage.

Yes but yards mean nothing without the TDs. The fact that wayne has 10 more TDs than any other QB in our league shows that he can hang it out there. Yards dont win games TDs do So in terms of who is the better QB wayne is by far.

Wayne has twice as many attempts as Norris. He also throws to receivers that 2-4 levels higher than our receivers. Just laying out more facts and stuff...

But without the TDs all the attempts and yardage means nothing. Imagine if tom brady threw for 3000 yards but only tossed 1 TD. He would be labeled a chump.

Your missing my point. Norris platoons and splits snaps with teel. Norris has roughly half the TDs of Wayne in roughly half the plays. Get it?

Teel and Norris combined have exact # of TDs as Wayne and your backup: 26

But anyway, I'm not saying Wayne doesn't deserve 1st team QB. Any guy who platoons in a system should expect to lose an all-star vote to a guy who gets all the snaps. And i agree with that too. But in terms of effectiveness in a game, I don't think Wayne has anything on us.

Originally posted by DeathKnight000
But without the TDs all the attempts and yardage means nothing. Imagine if tom brady threw for 3000 yards but only tossed 1 TD. He would be labeled a chump.

Not true, Tom Brady has only had one really outstanding season as far as touchdowns are concerned. He wasn't magically unlabeled as a chump for throwing TDs.

Was Troy Aikman a chump because he never put up huge TD numbers?

troy aikman was a chump cause michael strahan layed him on his ass his whole career BTW Giants > Patriots

Originally posted by Nike-Joe
DVSmith,

Just to set the record straight, Donnie Norris has the more Yards per Attempt and more yards per completion than Wayne. He also has a higher completion percentage.

Ok he also has double the INT's in 135 less passes. Wayne as a primary QB on our team still has a 103.6 QB rating which is higher. And Norris at times comes in against the opponents 2nd string players cause he was the backup. Wayne out their every game taking on starters from the 1st snap.

Originally posted by Nike-Joe
I don't think Wayne has anything on us.

That is where I disagree, Wayne does have something on you but maybe as a team Massacre don't have anything on Scarlett Knights. Thats what I am saying. I would take Wayne over either of your QB's. But I wouldn't say that our QB tandem is better than yours. So if it is best overall QB - Wayne wins hands down. If it is overall QB tandems then it wouldn't go either way.

DVSmith, I agree with that.

Being snubbed from the ballot seems to have motivated my RB/HB, Thanks!

I'm gonna say that these "nominations" don't cover all grounds. I know for FB's it's not always about running the ball. Mine is a pure blocker that clears the way for our HB's. He runs only occasionally on third and short usually. I'd say if we want to have a list here I say each owner gets to nominate 5-10 players from their roster...being 32 teams total you'd have to figure it out. But I figure that would be the best, because the owners know who their best players are, you can't always tell how good one of the players are based on their stats.

Originally posted by dannydbloody
you can't always tell how good one of the players are based on their stats.

I agree, hence my refusal to vote. It's almost impossible to accurately gauge how good a CB is without watching all the game film...which no one really wants to do.

Some other positions are the same.