A probowl game would be awesome. It would make the offseason more interesting. I think the top 10 players should be put into a ballot and owner vote for the top players(on other teams)
Maddencoach
offline
offline
yeah, the probowl list would be great even if they dont even play each other. Having a probowl team would just be a good thing for players progression.
justanley
offline
offline
Its a great idea. Why did DD and Bort not think of this.
Last edited Mar 22, 2009 15:27:09
Deathblade
offline
offline
The thread Pro Bowl has been merged into this thread
This was the OP
Originally posted by ij.cohen
I hate the MVP system because it seems to lean towards certain positions/stats and it doesn't necessarily vote for a player that is largely responsible for their team's success.
Instead, what I propose is that we implement a pro bowl system. Just like the NFL it could incorporate different votes, 1/3 votes from the players, 1/3 votes from the coaches/GMs, and 1/3 votes from the fans (cpu based on stats like MVP system is run now). Many leagues currently run a pro bowl voting system in their league forums and I think this would be much more fun of a way to run that system and keep track of throughout a player's career or even team's history. This way we find the best players from each position and not just "offensive mvp" which usually = HB anyways.
Also, I'm not sure if this could be done easily, but it would be REALLY awesome if we could run a pro bowl game in which all the players voted in could play a game with alpha versus zeta or eastern versus western or whatever. This game wouldn't allow for anyone to game plan or set any type of settings. Instead, it would be a game run like D-League where as it plays with a 98-99 energy swap out and incorporates all plays in the game. Just for teh lolz.
You could also have a vote for overall offense, defense, ST, and overall overall MVP as well. Just like NFL.
This was the OP
Originally posted by ij.cohen
I hate the MVP system because it seems to lean towards certain positions/stats and it doesn't necessarily vote for a player that is largely responsible for their team's success.
Instead, what I propose is that we implement a pro bowl system. Just like the NFL it could incorporate different votes, 1/3 votes from the players, 1/3 votes from the coaches/GMs, and 1/3 votes from the fans (cpu based on stats like MVP system is run now). Many leagues currently run a pro bowl voting system in their league forums and I think this would be much more fun of a way to run that system and keep track of throughout a player's career or even team's history. This way we find the best players from each position and not just "offensive mvp" which usually = HB anyways.
Also, I'm not sure if this could be done easily, but it would be REALLY awesome if we could run a pro bowl game in which all the players voted in could play a game with alpha versus zeta or eastern versus western or whatever. This game wouldn't allow for anyone to game plan or set any type of settings. Instead, it would be a game run like D-League where as it plays with a 98-99 energy swap out and incorporates all plays in the game. Just for teh lolz.
You could also have a vote for overall offense, defense, ST, and overall overall MVP as well. Just like NFL.
Edited by Deathblade on May 16, 2009 03:02:34
NEXT
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ron Rivera
+1 I love it
But what would players get out of this?
Trophies?
+1 I love it
But what would players get out of this?Trophies?
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Wont work because people vote for themselves or for their own teams. I don't know if you've been in leagues where they do Pro Bowl voting, but it ALWAYS pans out as simple campaigning for your own...
ij.cohen
offline
offline
I hate the MVP system because it seems to lean towards certain positions/stats and it doesn't necessarily vote for a player that is largely responsible for their team's success.
Instead, what I propose is that we implement a pro bowl system. Just like the NFL it could incorporate different votes, 1/3 votes from the players, 1/3 votes from the coaches/GMs, and 1/3 votes from the fans (cpu based on stats like MVP system is run now). Many leagues currently run a pro bowl voting system in their league forums and I think this would be much more fun of a way to run that system and keep track of throughout a player's career or even team's history. This way we find the best players from each position and not just "offensive mvp" which usually = HB anyways.
Also, I'm not sure if this could be done easily, but it would be REALLY awesome if we could run a pro bowl game in which all the players voted in could play a game with alpha versus zeta or eastern versus western or whatever. This game wouldn't allow for anyone to game plan or set any type of settings. Instead, it would be a game run like D-League where as it plays with a 98-99 energy swap out and incorporates all plays in the game. Just for teh lolz.
You could also have a vote for overall offense, defense, ST, and overall overall MVP as well. Just like NFL.
Instead, what I propose is that we implement a pro bowl system. Just like the NFL it could incorporate different votes, 1/3 votes from the players, 1/3 votes from the coaches/GMs, and 1/3 votes from the fans (cpu based on stats like MVP system is run now). Many leagues currently run a pro bowl voting system in their league forums and I think this would be much more fun of a way to run that system and keep track of throughout a player's career or even team's history. This way we find the best players from each position and not just "offensive mvp" which usually = HB anyways.
Also, I'm not sure if this could be done easily, but it would be REALLY awesome if we could run a pro bowl game in which all the players voted in could play a game with alpha versus zeta or eastern versus western or whatever. This game wouldn't allow for anyone to game plan or set any type of settings. Instead, it would be a game run like D-League where as it plays with a 98-99 energy swap out and incorporates all plays in the game. Just for teh lolz.
You could also have a vote for overall offense, defense, ST, and overall overall MVP as well. Just like NFL.
ij.cohen
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ron Rivera
+1 I love it But what would players get out of this?
Under the awards page it would list the season and league/team they played in and what spot they were voted in as pro bowl/mvp.
+1 I love it
But what would players get out of this?Under the awards page it would list the season and league/team they played in and what spot they were voted in as pro bowl/mvp.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
