Warrior General Games

Originally posted by Myd
The only issue with implementing the FFA voting system here would be it would become a popularity contest for people rather than for ideas.

Ding ding ding.

Suggestions needs to retain a mildly objective element. In the current system, where moderators push suggestion threads that have gathered some steam and are "good" to Catch, we have that. It's not perfect, but it works.

I'll be the first to fight for suggestions using some organization and more objective standards, but we're not there yet. Lord Pallow will grace us with implemented forum ideas eventually.

Originally posted by Myd
The only issue with implementing the FFA voting system here would be it would become a popularity contest for people rather than for ideas.

So true

Originally posted by Myd
The only issue with implementing the FFA voting system here would be it would become a popularity contest for people rather than for ideas.

very true and that has been the sticking point on this suggestion each time it has been brought up I think.

Originally posted by Myd
The only issue with implementing the FFA voting system here would be it would become a popularity contest for people rather than for ideas.

This. I made a suggestion for like three straight off-seasons. It would get maybe one reply and be on the second page the next day every time. When Dub suggested the same exact thing a couple days later it got hundreds of replies and was a great idea.

I've seen many great suggestions minus oned by trolls who really don't do much in game but try to control the forum. They never even attempt to give some kind of counter argument just hang around being jackasses. An example would be a guy with one free player who gives a -1 to a mass equipment up grader or such calling everyone lazy rather than giving a valid argument. Or the players who -1 anything that has to do with casual or peewee so everyone will think they are awesome. It's not nearly as bad as it was a few seasons ago but is enough to make me -1 this suggestion.