Warrior General Games

Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet
2 new awards for east and west

1 for an owner of the year

and not to leave the mose under appreciated players out 1 for the O Linemen

What about a clutch kicker award

Originally posted by salizy13
5 commisoners

Alright, what I do then? It seems like all these awards,mvp, pro bowl, and etc are all decided by the 5 same people.

Originally posted by Lgonzo
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

2 new awards for east and west

1 for an owner of the year

and not to leave the mose under appreciated players out 1 for the O Linemen

What about a clutch kicker award


K award added

good idea.

Only awards are chosen. I believe pro bowl is facillated by us

Yeah I like the best kicker award, and I think someone mentioned something about a Owner of the year, I also like that one.

How about the best drinker of the year?? Joe Diddy has that one in his hands as we speak!!

each teams owner should have a say

Originally posted by PakiRaider
each teams owner should have a say

The Commissioners keep bias out of the picture and keep it from getting too messy.

Im fine with this as long as the teams who have the commisioners dont unbiasedly make up 70% of the awards and pro bowl votes. Now naturally Tecmo is going to have a ton of Pro bowlers and that is expected since they are a very good team but It should be very difficult for their players to be league MVP for that same reason, When your team is amazing it boosts your level of play therefor a great season by a player on a bad team is more valuable than a great season by a player on a stacked team, just my opinion.

But isnt mvp suppose to be the most valuable player you have? The guy if you lose your team drops off a lot? I mean if the MVP is on a crap team that wins 5 games I dont think he is that "valuable." I have no problem if Serenity's QB wins (assume thats the favorite). I think it should be taken into account that she has better weapons, but if another QB on a 6-10 team has similar numbers I dont think they should automatically get it.

Originally posted by gambrinus843
Im fine with this as long as the teams who have the commisioners dont unbiasedly make up 70% of the awards and pro bowl votes. Now naturally Tecmo is going to have a ton of Pro bowlers and that is expected since they are a very good team but It should be very difficult for their players to be league MVP for that same reason, When your team is amazing it boosts your level of play therefor a great season by a player on a bad team is more valuable than a great season by a player on a stacked team, just my opinion.

obviously no one from my team will be on the list unless they truly deserve it

Im just saying if you manage to have similar numbers with subpar talent then you are obviously at least a little more valuable to your team than a guy who can be replaced with the 2nd stringer and due to the overwhelming talent around him still succeed with good numbers. I wasnt bashing tecmo or anyone in particular I just wanted to voice my opinion on an MVP decision because just having the best stats does not mean you are the most valuable player to a team, if that 6-10 team loses its one guy they go 1-15 whereas the powerhouse loses its star and goes from 14-2 to 13-3 its not as big a dropoff.

Personally I dont think we in Honolulu have a guy who would be up for MVP because I dont feel there is anyone that if he were to go down...(I know there are no injuries in the sim) that we would not be able to compensate for, we have a pretty balanced team and if one guy goes down someone else can fill in adequately.

Originally posted by gambrinus843
Personally I dont think we in Honolulu have a guy who would be up for MVP because I dont feel there is anyone that if he were to go down...(I know there are no injuries in the sim) that we would not be able to compensate for, we have a pretty balanced team and if one guy goes down someone else can fill in adequately.

That's a horrible theory when it comes to choosing an MVP. You pick the best player who's performed "the best". His statistics are going to be plays from the game so it obviously helped his team that much. If HNL does not have a guy who stands out in the league then ok got it, but if your RB has like 2500 yards/40 TDs/6.8 Average/ and the next RB is like 1450 Yds/21 TDs/5.1 Average it does not matter to be if you have another level 16 backing him up. He did that and it's a hell of an accomplishment.

Originally posted by Unconquered
Originally posted by gambrinus843

Personally I dont think we in Honolulu have a guy who would be up for MVP because I dont feel there is anyone that if he were to go down...(I know there are no injuries in the sim) that we would not be able to compensate for, we have a pretty balanced team and if one guy goes down someone else can fill in adequately.

That's a horrible theory when it comes to choosing an MVP. You pick the best player who's performed "the best". His statistics are going to be plays from the game so it obviously helped his team that much. If HNL does not have a guy who stands out in the league then ok got it, but if your RB has like 2500 yards/40 TDs/6.8 Average/ and the next RB is like 1450 Yds/21 TDs/5.1 Average it does not matter to be if you have another level 16 backing him up. He did that and it's a hell of an accomplishment.

i agree completely