^Pretty much where I'm thinking buddy.

Just one thing though. "Otherwise it would run the risk of every team nominating the same big positions, and ending up with an all star team full of WRs, QBs and LBs or something silly like that." With the depth of all different players in this league, I'm sure different teams are stronger at different positions, so I'm sure there would be nominations for players that don't play in "big positions".
