Warrior General Games

Keep Kelly out of top 10 QB talks.

Aikman too.

Originally posted by Team Nucleus
Jeff Garcia was Rice happy then

he wasn't even the qb then.

Originally posted by Team Nucleus
You said Bledsoe

Yeah, not a great all-timer...I might put Fran over him, though not by all that much.

Originally posted by tautology
Yeah, not a great all-timer...I might put Fran over him, though not by all that much.
no u

Originally posted by jdbolick

You're not giving Fran nearly enough credit, but you grotesquely overvaluing team success helps explain why. QBs need to be accurate and avoid turnovers. Tarkenton was one of the best of his era at both while playing on some truly wretched teams.

Fran racked up a lot of stats against teams that didn't care all that much. He just didn't really strike fear into anyone even in his prime. Stabler did, and so did Staubach....folks expected them to carry the team in big games, and they did it often enough to remember.

Originally posted by jdbolick

Putting Bradshaw on the list immediately makes you look ridiculous.

prob have him closer to 14 or 15..........

4 rings but ver;y inconsistent (could be top 5 for that but it is a team game)
his stats would put him in a top 20 so not that impressive
solid rusher
one reg season mvp and 2 playoffs mvps

fran would be top 5 if he had any rings....

2 more bowl appearances than marino....and if u normalize he stats to adjust for their eras, Tarkenton actually beats out Marino in several statistical categories including career passing yards and passer rating . though he had one of the best defensive dynasties of the 60s and 70s to help him get there

big ben >every other QB who ever played
Turner> every RB
Roddy White> best WR
Tony Gonzalez> every TE



im srs bout tony da g.

Big Ben isn't even the best QB in his own era.

Also... randomly Montana was on Dan Patrick this morning and was asked how he felt when people called him a system QB:

"Well, I got 4 of those system rings."

Originally posted by Homage
Big Ben isn't even the best QB in his own era.

hes not even the best qb on his team. batch. nuff said

i'd like to point out that at this point this thread is off-topic and should therefore be locked.

Originally posted by Gart888
i'd like to point out that at this point this thread is off-topic and should therefore be locked.



Done

Thread moved by moderator.

Re-branded

Originally posted by Gart888
i'd like to point out that at this point this thread is off-topic and should therefore be locked.

I do good work