Warrior General Games

Originally posted by CyberNinja
OL sucked, no HB, Lynn Swann was his only go to WR come on JD
OL was quite good, Franco Harris, and John Stallworth. Bradshaw had a whole bunch of seasons in Tim Tebow territory when it comes to completion percentage, plus he was awful about turning the ball over. I'd say he was the most overrated QB of all-time if Joe Namath didn't already kiss that title on national television.

Originally posted by jdbolick

Campbell's first three seasons were incredible, but he was average and then pretty terrible after that. As for Sayers, four out of AP's five seasons have been better than any Gale ever had. Bo Jackson is a better example of a tremendously short but brilliant career than Sayers.



Fair enough...I still have a hard time with AP at #2, despite the monster season he's currently having. Too soon. imo.

Originally posted by jdbolick

No. I like Drew and I said in our magazine at the time that San Diego was making a huge mistake by letting him go, but his numbers in New Orleans aren't an accurate reflection of him the same way that Emmitt Smith's aren't.


Drew's numbers are gaudy in part due to the system, but the system works because Drew is amazing. It cuts both ways.

I watched Fran play and he was certainly better than a journeyman, but not a top 10 of all time guy. I'd put Staubach, Bradshaw and Stabler over him from that generation, and I'd put Fouts, Jim Kelly and maybe Ken Anderson over him from the next generation.

Originally posted by Team Nucleus
#1 QB Tom Brady and still playing
#1 HB split decision Barry Sanders and Walter Payton
#1 WR hands down Randy Moss



#1 WR is Jerry Rice without a doubt.

Originally posted by bhall43
#1 WR is Jerry Rice without a doubt.

yep.

Originally posted by Team Nucleus
#1 QB Tom Brady and still playing
#1 HB split decision Barry Sanders and Walter Payton
#1 WR hands down Randy Moss


#1 HB is Jim Brown. That is not debatable. #1 WR is obviously Jerry Rice. Ah, you're trolling; I'm slow.

Originally posted by bhall43
#1 WR is Jerry Rice without a doubt.

Rice had Montana for almost more than half his career.
Moss had Culpepper for most of his.
Easy decision

Originally posted by jdbolick

#1 HB is Jim Brown. That is not debatable. #1 WR is obviously Jerry Rice. Ah, you're trolling; I'm slow.

Barry Sanders had no O-Line and played for the Lions. Easy there also

Originally posted by Bane
I paid 20$ for my Windy City Grizzlies logo http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=354

But the guy never put a price on it, he just said any donation would be fine. I could have only gave him a buck (or nada even)

He was happy with the 20 though, and I'm still doing fine without that money

eta: and not from the site in OP

lol why'd you pay 20 bucks for a gif version of the memphis grizzlies logo with bad text?

Originally posted by Team Nucleus
Rice had Montana for almost more than half his career.
Moss had Culpepper for most of his.
Easy decision
Culpepper was actually a really good QB before blowing out his knee. He had one of the best years of all-time in 2004 even though Moss was injured much of that season.

Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by tautology

I watched Fran play and he was certainly better than a journeyman, but not a top 10 of all time guy. I'd put Staubach, Bradshaw and Stabler over him from that generation, and I'd put Fouts, Jim Kelly and maybe Ken Anderson over him from the next generation.
Originally posted by jdbolick

Putting Bradshaw on the list immediately makes you look ridiculous.

I hated Bradshaw when he played, so it's tough for me to defend him with too much passion...but 4 rings is 4 rings. He definitely had some meltdown seasons though (in part due to injury).

Originally posted by jdbolick

Culpepper was actually a really good QB before blowing out his knee. He had one of the best years of all-time in 2004 even though Moss was injured much of that season.

He looked good only due to Chris Carter being there a short time and Moss stacking up his numbers.
What happened when Carter and Moss left? He became a bum

But Tarkenton is even more ridiculous.

AP and Favre in the #2 spots proves why no one can find your magazine on store shelves

Moss is too one dimensional and he can't even start for the 49ers right now. Jerry Rice was starting for a superbowl team and making the pro bowl in his 18th season in the NFL.