Warrior General Games

Instead of having Kickers and Punters who do different things compete against each other.

Why?

They don't separate QBs, HBs, and WRs for Offensive MVP. They do different things.

Not for MVPs...but yeah a loltrophy for the top at each position would be cool.

I dont really know if K and P deserve separate MVPs since all of the O/D gets grouped into 2 MVPs

and they have already split them out from the ST MVP race

Originally posted by reddogrw
and they have already split them out from the ST MVP race

do they, didn't realize it

Originally posted by reddogrw
and they have already split them out from the ST MVP race

I think he is asking for them to split it out even further

which I don't see them doing unless they are going to implement some kind of pro bowl system, as to do it for all positions

yeah - for ST it would be:

best kicker

best punter

best returner

best coverage / blocking STer

Originally posted by reddogrw
yeah - for ST it would be:

best kicker

best punter

best returner

best coverage / blocking STer

But then we'd also need Best QB, Best RB, Best WR, Best TE, Best OL....

you already have a 1 in 32 chance of winning it just by being a K or a punter, you want a 1 in 16 chance? its probalby even more of a chance after you factor in the fact that CPU dots cant win MVP.

makes sense, and all for doing Originally posted by reddogrw
yeah - for ST it would be:

best kicker

best punter

best returner

best coverage / blocking STer

but there's already 2 for ST and only 1 each for O and D, so once you have 4 for ST you need to have at least 4 for O and 3

Qb/passer
Hb/Fb/rusher
Te/Wr/reciever

DL
Lb
Db

so you might as well just have an MVP for each position, which would be getting out of hand. better to have it like real pro football and have just one (and make the formulas better so it wouldn't the same guys all the time like rushing QBs, scat FBs and pass rushing DEs)

Everyone gets a trophy!

Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Everyone gets a trophy!

+1

Originally posted by fogie55
makes sense, and all for doing Originally posted by reddogrw

yeah - for ST it would be:

best kicker

best punter

best returner

best coverage / blocking STer

but there's already 2 for ST and only 1 each for O and D, so once you have 4 for ST you need to have at least 4 for O and 3

Qb/passer
Hb/Fb/rusher
Te/Wr/reciever

DL
Lb
Db

so you might as well just have an MVP for each position, which would be getting out of hand. better to have it like real pro football and have just one (and make the formulas better so it wouldn't the same guys all the time like rushing QBs, scat FBs and pass rushing DEs)



exactly

it has already split out

personally, keep the MVP trophy's as is and add all-pro trophies by conference - would be cool, especially for OL and DT's