It's pretty dumb that this was added in the first place. There is no defensive equivalent and it adds even more RNG to a game that has more than enough of it.
Forum > Suggestions > Get Rid of False Start
DarkRogue
offline
offline
Originally posted by PatrickStump
doesn't vision help it though?
which makes it even worse, vision is very high for dots at low levels and that's when offense is at it's worse
doesn't vision help it though?
which makes it even worse, vision is very high for dots at low levels and that's when offense is at it's worse
Penalties should be in the game
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
fogie55
offline
offline
Originally posted by Diamond Spade
the defense equivalent to false start is encroachment penalty
the defense equivalent to false start is encroachment penalty
Originally posted by Daver
there should be face masking as well
dots don't have faces
there should be face masking as well
dots don't have faces
Driley10
offline
offline
Originally posted by yello1
Penalties should be in the game
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
Actualy love this idea, kinda makes me think of what NCAA football has.
Penalties should be in the game
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
Actualy love this idea, kinda makes me think of what NCAA football has.
fogie55
offline
offline
it would be nice to tone down or eliminate the number of penalties at the pee wee /rookie levels
Here's the BIG reason why I support this OP. It's literally the ONLY penalty GLB has going. As Yellow posted... would like to see a much more realistic penalty system where pass interference (offensive and defensive), off sides (which currently IS a penalty but hardly ever seems to get called), facemask, holding, and such stuff exists. Having only 2 available penalties currently sucks balls. It's inherently unfair that it mostly only effects a small few dots (most notably O-line and D-line). If we can't have "realistic penalties" (for now, anyways)... then why have any at all? Which is why I give my +1 to this.
Dub J
offline
offline
+1
A hundred years ago Bort had planned for more varieties of penalties in this game. Hasn't happened and even changed SAs in a manner that tells us he's not adding them. Either do something all the way or don't do it at all.
A hundred years ago Bort had planned for more varieties of penalties in this game. Hasn't happened and even changed SAs in a manner that tells us he's not adding them. Either do something all the way or don't do it at all.
tjsexkitten82
offline
offline
Originally posted by yello1
Penalties should be in the game
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
Would love it.
Penalties should be in the game
But they should be slider based, a result of tactical choices that give a benefit versus the risk of penalty. Like the encroachment VA but just a tactical thing.
That said a random chance of one based on vision for these two penalties does make sense, sometimes they just get dumb. Really a random chance of a personal foul would make sense as well for the same reason.
Wouldnt miss em if gone but I think this one RNG is a good touch of football flavor the game is better off with than without.
Would love it.
Time Trial
offline
offline
Originally posted by DarkRogue
It's pretty dumb that this was added in the first place. There is no defensive equivalent and it adds even more RNG to a game that has more than enough of it.
There is encroachment.
Both should be removed from the game until Bort codes more penalties into the game. It really only affects the Pee Wee and Rookie teams, after that the penalties aren't that frequent.
It's pretty dumb that this was added in the first place. There is no defensive equivalent and it adds even more RNG to a game that has more than enough of it.
There is encroachment.
Both should be removed from the game until Bort codes more penalties into the game. It really only affects the Pee Wee and Rookie teams, after that the penalties aren't that frequent.
_OSIRIS_
offline
offline
Originally posted by Time Trial
There is encroachment.
Both should be removed from the game until Bort codes more penalties into the game. It really only affects the Pee Wee and Rookie teams, after that the penalties aren't that frequent.
Encroachment is not really an equilivent because it is very rare compared to false starts. I was ready to quit this game a few seasons back because of false starts. It has been toned back and with good vision and confidence rarely is called now.
There is encroachment.
Both should be removed from the game until Bort codes more penalties into the game. It really only affects the Pee Wee and Rookie teams, after that the penalties aren't that frequent.
Encroachment is not really an equilivent because it is very rare compared to false starts. I was ready to quit this game a few seasons back because of false starts. It has been toned back and with good vision and confidence rarely is called now.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
