Warrior General Games

For top defense plays, can it include all the pass plays in which the def player was the target??

Originally posted by c5family20
For top defense plays, can it include all the pass plays in which the def player was the target??
You want the Suggestions forum: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=2

This is a forum for changes that either 1) have been announced, or 2) have already been implemented. Good luck!

Thread moved by moderator.

Defense is always tricky in the whole stats thing - even in the real NFL. The best CBs are not the ones that have the most targets with the fewest receptions allowed - the best CBs are the ones who are so good that they never get targeted at all.

So, while in theory I like the idea of this in general, it's a slippery slope to start messing with how plays and players in general are ranked. For every idea one person can come up with, I can come up with 5 others that are just as good and just as logical.

This is completely different from the stat argument.

RBs get a fumble listed as a top play...OL get hurries allowed list as a top play et c.

I think this is a good thing. If it helps think about "top replays" as the most important replays of the game. And for that reason I think it would be good to include anytime the defensive player is targeted.

There are the lines like my CB had in a scrimmage today...5 targets, 0 rec allowed, 1 PD. I have no need to see the 4 "targeted" plays listed where I know he really didn't do anything??

Originally posted by Greywolfmeb
There are the lines like my CB had in a scrimmage today...5 targets, 0 rec allowed, 1 PD. I have no need to see the 4 "targeted" plays listed where I know he really didn't do anything??

I hear you but wonder why you simply not select those plays for reviewing? That's what I do if I don't want to watch a certain "top play". But as a coach, I also WANT to see ALL "top plays"... even if it isn't my dot. I often wish there was 2 forms of "Top Plays"... one for the Dot's owner and one for the team. (And I know scoring plays are listed on the game page... but not things like 4th down stops/conversions and turnovers, ect, ect.)