Warrior General Games

Originally posted by this_guy1015
thumps up on suggestion forums instead of on trash talking threads. +1 for this idea though

Dont tell me why this would be stupid tell me why it hasnt happened yet.

+ 1 kinda makes the most sense

-1

FFA and GD have already proven how flawed the karma system is which means that's the last thing we need here.

-1 no more of this

Karma system ≠ voting system

The last thing you want is a few quick thumbs down locking a potentially good suggestion.

Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Karma system ≠ voting system

The last thing you want is a few quick thumbs down locking a potentially good suggestion.

It takes days of coordinated effort to lock a thread in GD through the multis +1ing it.

I think you might be exaggerating a bit with the "few quick thumbs down" thing.

Not to mention that the locking threshold is adjustable.

However the suggestions are up for vote on http://goallineblitz.com/game/suggestions.pl is how it should be on normal suggestions too

Originally posted by this_guy1015
However the suggestions are up for vote on http://goallineblitz.com/game/suggestions.pl is how it should be on normal suggestions too

those are all normal suggestions....

Originally posted by bigtisme
those are all normal suggestions....

but they dont lock after a certain amount of negative votes is what im saying

-_-

why can't the voting just be for the simple purpose of a thumbs up you agree witht he suggestion and thumbs down you disagree. it doesn't have to be just like the stuff in FFA. it could be a very useful tool if used correctly. and I do not think it would be something that would necessarily have to work the same way it does in FFA. just cut the locking of the thread out and use it for the pure purpose of agreeing or disagreeing with a suggestion.

Originally posted by hatchman
why can't the voting just be for the simple purpose of a thumbs up you agree witht he suggestion and thumbs down you disagree. it doesn't have to be just like the stuff in FFA. it could be a very useful tool if used correctly. and I do not think it would be something that would necessarily have to work the same way it does in FFA. just cut the locking of the thread out and use it for the pure purpose of agreeing or disagreeing with a suggestion.

I think you are overestimating the value of customer feedback.

Most users don't know what the fuck they actually want.

Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by hatchman

why can't the voting just be for the simple purpose of a thumbs up you agree witht he suggestion and thumbs down you disagree. it doesn't have to be just like the stuff in FFA. it could be a very useful tool if used correctly. and I do not think it would be something that would necessarily have to work the same way it does in FFA. just cut the locking of the thread out and use it for the pure purpose of agreeing or disagreeing with a suggestion.

I think you are overestimating the value of customer feedback.

Most users don't know what the fuck they actually want.

true to some extent. but the karma system could be useful in the suggestions forum. I know there would need to be some tweaks to keep all the childish BS from happening in here like it does in FFA. but its usefullness would be welcomed by most I would think.

Originally posted by Deathblade
I think you are overestimating the value of customer feedback.

Most users don't know what the fuck they actually want.

did you really have to use the F word?