User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Position Talk > WR Club > So 5 Wide Receivers walked onto a field. . .
Link
 
and strapped on helmets.

A has 116 speed and 66 agility
B has 113 speed and 71 agility
C has 101 speed and 88 agility
D has 103 speed and 70 agility
E has 103 speed and 78 agility

Assume all other height/weight attributes, primary and secondary skills, SA's, VA's and decline nos. are the same.

Who does the coach start?
 
Bully Ben
offline
Link
 
Actually I like D the best. The ratio of speed to agility is where I like it the best. But where are the rest of his points. That would factor in also. Jumping, catching, carrying, Strength, SA's? They cannot be the same unless he is a lower level.

B would be my 2nd choice.

A takes too long to get up to top speed.

And D obviously has points else where compared to C and E as they have 18 and 8 more agility points with pretty close to the same speed, unless again, poor training or lower level.

 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bully Ben
Actually I like D the best. The ratio of speed to agility is where I like it the best. But where are the rest of his points. That would factor in also. Jumping, catching, carrying, Strength, SA's? They cannot be the same unless he is a lower level.

B would be my 2nd choice.

A takes too long to get up to top speed.

And D obviously has points else where compared to C and E as they have 18 and 8 more agility points with pretty close to the same speed, unless again, poor training or lower level.



Why in the world would you take D over E? None om them are really that good, but C could be good if used correctly...
Edited by kwankwan on Jan 12, 2010 18:04:34
 
kcdizz
offline
Link
 
C, only 2 less speed then E and 10 more agility. they all need more speed
 
The_Jonas
offline
Link
 
Start B and C
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
C and hope the secondary attributes involve a healthy dose of catching carrying and strength for catching in coverage and possibly pulling off some spins. if C can't do that then you should just run the ball
 
regoob2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kcdizz
C, only 2 less speed then E and 10 more agility. they all need more speed


 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
All other things equal? C starts no doubt. Most balanced.
 
Link
 
C no doubt
 
kerpow
offline
Link
 
B and C, could work well toegther. Others are all sub-par.
Edited by kerpow on Jan 16, 2010 19:57:18
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.