Warrior General Games

Which one do u guys think is the better pick to return kicks this season. My Wr build is open, i just reset my VA's but i had 5 pts in return man and 2 pts in special teamer. i have 4 eq with +4 spd and one with +4 spd +3 return specialist SA. he has all basic eq and not sure what there put into but doesnt have lvl 32 eq yet. his SA are: 4 first step, 6 change direction, 11 return specialist, 3 blitz, 3 closing speed and 7 in the special teams VA. And his attributes vs my WR are as follows:

WR cb
strength 11 23
speed 94.6 86.4
agility 64.6 49.3
jumping 23.6 34.3
stamina 30.6 48.3
vision 51.6 43.3
confidence 32 23
blocking 10 8
tackling 10 31
catching 30.6 21.3
carrying 28 28

Oh and we both have +6 attribute and +1 SA custom eq and to see my SA's here is my profile
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=942225

Be honest i dont take it personal and thanks for your time

oh and i was also wondering if someone would rate my WR as a KR/PR for his level, good or just decent?

Returning kicks drains ALOT of energy. Depends what else the players have to do on the team and where they are on the depth chart. Based on what you've given here, I'd probably use the WR. He seems to have superior stats (speed, agility, vision).

im assuming this is the consensus idea because nobody else has replied, thanks. i just thought it was weird my WR was the only return guy for the last few seasons and all of a sudden a new guy who says he is going to up the stats in the KR/PR columns, and in my opinion, even 3 levels lower, my looks like the better guy even though the cb has 11 in return specialist, but from the stuff ive read, ive heard that the cb would be the third guy to use in KR/PR behind the WR and HB.

I choose the WR based on his agi/vis. His only downside is his stamina. The CB gets the advantage on return specialist but assuming equal VAs I'd still have to choose the WR.